Transmutation

From Anthroposophy

Certain processes in nature cause physical elements to undergo a biological transmutation into other physical elements. This happens in plants (see: Plant kingdom) and also in the organs of Man's metabolic system.

What takes places in Nature and in Man can be described by the ancient principle of 'solve et coagula' as explained on Alchemy, or a more modern spiritual scientific language The two etheric forces.

In the scientific paradigm of mineral science, the fact that a physical element would change is impossible and defies the laws of (mineral) physics. An explanation of this apparent paradox is given by the fact that mineral science limits its scope to the mineral element 'earth' and does not study the laws of the etheric (represented by the element 'water'), see Formative forces and the 1921-06-GA205 reference.

The same applies to Potentization, the principle underlying homeopathy, which is also based on the laws of the etheric forces.

Transmutation was discovered and studied extensively in the 19th century by Albrecht von Herzeele (see coverage below). Rudolf Steiner confirmed this principle of transmutation, and experiments were redone in the 20th century by a.o. Rudolf Hauschka, Louis Kervran and Wim Holleman. Nevertheless (as so many things), this is today regarded fringe or pseudo science, and rediculized by mineral science. See further: worldview wars.

Aspects

Illustrations

Schema FMC00.011 shows an example of experimental results, from Rudolf Hauschka laboratory experiments in the years 1934-1940 that confirmed von Herzeele's findings (see References below). Because the tests were continued over years, it shows that the moon rhythm is subservient to a stronger annual sun rhythm. Notice how the curves show a powerful dynamic upto say June period, whereas in the second year-half there is hardly any dynamic. Also remarkable is the 'cross-over' where the new-moon minima overrides the full-moon maxima curve around the June period, after which both curves quiet down.

FMC00.011.jpg


Lecture coverage and references

Albrecht von Herzeele

.. (1821-unknown) spend most of his life investigating the apparently innocent question: 'Where do the minerals in plants come from?'

Von Herzeele grew plants without soil, using solutions whose mineral content he measured and controlled. He found that germinating seeds without a supply of calcium had an increase of calcium in the young plants analyzed 30 days after they germinated. Like scientists before him in England, France and Germany he found that there were elements in the ashes of the plants he grew that could not have got in from the growth medium. He concluded that 'plants are capable of effecting the transmutation of elements.'

In 1873 he published 'The origin of inorganic substances' (Der Ursprung anorganischser Substanzen), in later works he published some five hundred analysis on his experimental data between 1875 and 1883, all based on his experiments with germinating seeds.

After determining the seeds' average calcium content, he let the rest of the seeds germinate (sprout) under conditions where they were completely isolated from any source of additional calcium. According to the invariance theory, the total amount of calcium in the isolated seeds should have remained constant throughout all subsequent growth. However, when Von Herzeele analyzed the seeds after thirty days, he found that they contained a good deal more calcium than had been present initially. Logically, two explanations appeared most likely. Either the additional calcium had been 'created' (formed out of something that was not physical matter), or else the calcium atoms had come from the transmutation of one element into another.

His findings outraged the scientific community and his books were removed from libraries and his writings banned. Even today the subject is a taboo question that can scarcely be mentioned in scientific circles. Nevertheless he was not the first or only to report this, as similar experiments were done before, and also afterwards.

Rudolf Steiner

The following famous quote by Rudolf Steiner comes from a lecture in the agriculture course on 1924-06-13-GA327

There is something you must know in this connection. For the scientists of to-day it will no longer argue such entire confusion on our part as it would have done a short time ago. Are not they themselves already speaking frankly of a transmutation of the elements? Observation of several elements has tamed the materialistic lion in this respect, if I may say so. Processes, however, that are taking place around us all the time are as yet utterly unknown. If they were known, people would more readily believe such things as I have just explained.

I know quite well, those who have studied academic agriculture from the modern point of view will say: “You have still not told us how to improve the nitrogen-content of the manure.” On the contrary, I have been speaking of it all the time, namely, in speaking of yarrow, camomile and stinging nettle. For there is a hidden alchemy in the organic process. This hidden alchemy really transmutes the potash, for example, into nitrogen, provided only that the potash is working properly in the organic process. Nay more, it even transforms into nitrogen the limestone, the chalky nature, if it is working rightly.

You know that in the growth of plants, all the four elements of which I have been speaking are involved. Hydrogen also is there, in addition to sulphur. I have told you of the significance of hydrogen. Now there is a mutual and qualitative relationship between the limestone and the hydrogen, similar to that between oxygen and nitrogen in the air.

Even externally, in a quantitative chemical analysis as it were, the relationship between the oxygen-nitrogen connection in the air, and the limestone-hydrogen connection in the organic processes, might well be revealed. The fact is that under the influence of hydrogen, limestone and potash are constantly being transmuted into something very little nitrogen, and at length into actual nitrogen.

And the nitrogen which is formed in this way is of the greatest benefit to plant-growth. We must enable it to be thus engendered by methods such as I have here described.

See also 1921-06-03-GA204 on Blood is a special fluid, as the extract describes: food is only changed into blood through the Earth's influence after having passed through the walls of the intestines into the organism. Only there does the Earth's influence begin.

Scientific research in the 20th century
  • Rudolf Hauschka (1891-1961) re-did the same experiments of von Herzeele in the period 1934-40, see Schema FMC00.011
  • So also did Pierre Baranger (1900-1970) in the period 1950-70, producing a wealth of experimental data and findings. However he received opposition by the established scientific community and was not able to get his results published. Even posthumous publication in the 1970s efforts failed.
  • The best-known modern researcher of biological transmutation is Louis Kervran (1901-1983) who started experiments around 1935 but was wise to withhold from publishing until much later (first key paper in 1960), and smart (like Darwin) to actively promote his work also through conferences and modern media. He wrote a number of books in the period 1962-1982 (french), some translated in English, a.o. 'Biological Transmutations'. Though he was nominated for the Nobel price in 1975, he also received his fair share of being rediculed by the established communities of materialistic mineral science. In the context of worldview wars, an illustration of the latter is the parodic Ig Nobel price awarded to Kervran in 1993 for his 'improbable research'
  • Rudolf Steiner's quote above also inspired Wim Holleman (1906-1994) who did his experiments in the timeframe 1975-1989

Discussion

  • This is sometimes also referred to, rather unfortunately as 'cold fusion', because in current physics one physical element can not change into another except through nuclear fusion at extreme conditions of temperature and pressure.

Related pages

Further reading and references

  • Albrecht von Herzeele: 'Der Ursprung anorganischer Substanzen' (1873)
  • Rudolf Hauschka: 'The nature of substance' (1950, 1966 in EN)
  • Coretin Louis Kervran:
    • 'Biological Transmutations' (1971)
    • website (DE/EN) dedicated to the work of Louis Kervran, with an overview of his many writings and books
  • Wim Holleman
    • the Holleman foundation website has a review of all research on transmutation of chemical elements including an overview of Holleman's work, (see downloadable 85 page PDF document), translations of von Herzeele and others writings, and further links
  • Jean-Paul Biberian: Biological transmutations: historical perspective (2012)
    • overview paper on historical research with extensive references section